Direct answer: migrate off shared hosting when the site's needs outgrow a shared plan — sustained traffic, heavy WooCommerce, staging/dev workflow, or a renewal bill that already rivals a flat managed plan — not because a blog post said “everyone needs a server.”
This page stays on hosting economics and WordPress/shared fit. It is not a root-access or SSH control-plane guide; that thesis lives on Best VPS Match. In our 12 June 2026 file, shared leaders such as SiteGround (score 88, True 3-Year Cost $408) and Hostinger (score 87, $276) still cover most brochure and early-commerce sites. Managed WordPress such as Kinsta sits at a flat $35/mo and $1,260 over three years with performance 96 and support 96. When your shared renewal approaches that kind of managed bill — SiteGround renews at $14.99/mo — it is time to re-run True 3-Year Cost and decide whether staying shared still wins. Affiliate links are not active.
Data verified 12 June 2026. Scores follow the published methodology. Paid placement is not accepted, and affiliate links are not active.
| Option | Category | True 3-Year Cost | Editorial score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hostinger | Shared | $276 | 87 |
| SiteGround | Shared | $408 | 88 |
| Bluehost | Shared | $323 | 82 |
| Kinsta | Managed WordPress | $1,260 | 89 |
Re-check the bill with True 3-Year Cost, browse best WordPress hosting and high-traffic hosting, then compare SiteGround vs Kinsta when the question is shared-premium versus flat managed WordPress. If you truly need root and a control plane, use Best VPS Match — that is a different buyer job.
No. Slow checkout, repeated resource-limit errors, needing reliable staging, or a renewal that rivals managed WordPress are equally valid triggers. Traffic is one signal among several.
Only if you need root-level control for custom stacks. For WordPress performance and support without that ops burden, compare managed WordPress first — see best WordPress hosting and SiteGround vs Kinsta on this site. VPS root/SSH matching belongs on bestvpsmatch.com.
If two more shared renewal years will cost nearly as much as a flat managed plan, the “cheap shared” story is already gone. Example: SiteGround's three-year total is $408; Kinsta's is $1,260 with no renewal jump.
Stay on quality shared hosting. Beginners and small-business guides on this site rank Hostinger, SiteGround, Bluehost, and DreamHost for that stage.